This is actually a great idea and one we do in my own company. We call it “premium shipping”. We basically just eliminate some economy services. We use Shipstation to tag orders that have requested service as premium shipping. Then, we use Shippingplus.co to create a segment that targets these orders and then create a rate shopping action where we only include the carriers we want to be considered. Works like a charm. Requires the use of shipping plus, which works really well with ShipStation. highly recommend you check them out if you’re interested in something like this. We make a killing by just charging a slight premium on “premium shipping”
